中文Resources › History of Economic Thought › Topic 1
Surplus, Markets, and the Birth of Capitalism
Before there was economics, there had to be an economy that seemed to run by its own laws. This module traces how capitalism emerged in Europe and how the first economic thinkers, the mercantilists and the physiocrats, tried to understand it.
1. Economics or political economy?
The word “economics” comes from the Greek oikonomia, the management of a household, the subject of Xenophon’s Oeconomicus and of a famous passage in Aristotle’s Politics. For most of its history, however, the subject this course studies was called political economy, from polis, the city-state: the management of the wealth of a whole society, with its classes, laws, and states. The change of name, which came only in the late nineteenth century, was also a change of questions. This course follows both.
From moral philosophy to political economy
In the universities of early modern Europe, most secular learning outside the professional faculties of theology, law, and medicine was “philosophy,” divided into two great branches. Natural philosophy studied nature; Isaac Newton’s great work of 1687 was titled Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy. Moral philosophy studied human beings and society: ethics, natural law, politics, and the management of wealth. “Science,” from the Latin scientia, simply meant any organized body of knowledge, so it was natural to speak of the “moral sciences” as well as the natural ones.
The idea of applying household management to a whole kingdom appeared in the seventeenth century: the French writer Antoine de Montchrestien titled a book Traicté de l’œconomie politique (1615). In the German lands, the equivalent was cameralism, the science of administering a prince’s state and treasury. James Steuart’s Inquiry into the Principles of Political Oeconomy (1767) was the first major English book to carry the name in its title.
Adam Smith (Topic 2) shows the transition in a single career. As professor of moral philosophy at Glasgow, he lectured on natural theology, ethics, jurisprudence, and, under the heading of “police, revenue, and arms,” on the economy. His Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) grew out of the ethics lectures, and The Wealth of Nations (1776) out of the last part. Political economy then became a subject of its own. Antonio Genovesi held an early chair in Naples (1754); Thomas Malthus was appointed professor of history and political economy at the East India Company’s college in 1805, often called the first such post in Britain; and Oxford founded the Drummond chair of political economy in 1825.
Meanwhile natural philosophy turned into “science” in the modern sense; William Whewell coined the word “scientist” in the 1830s. Political economy stayed on the moral side. John Stuart Mill (Topic 5) classed it among the “moral sciences,” and from 1851 Cambridge taught it within the Moral Sciences Tripos, alongside philosophy, history, and law, while a separate Natural Sciences Tripos covered the sciences of nature. Throughout this period, political economy studied the wealth of nations and how it is divided among landlords, capitalists, and workers. When Marx subtitled Capital (1867) “A Critique of Political Economy” (Topic 6), he was criticizing an established discipline under that name.
From political economy to economics
The single word “economics” spread between 1870 and 1930. In the preface to the second edition of The Theory of Political Economy (1879), W. S. Jevons (Topic 8) proposed discarding “the old troublesome double-worded name of our Science” in favor of “the single convenient term Economics,” on the model of “mathematics” and “ethics.” In the same year Alfred Marshall and Mary Paley Marshall published The Economics of Industry, and Marshall’s Principles of Economics (1890) made the new name standard in English (Topic 9). In 1903 Marshall persuaded Cambridge to create a separate Economics Tripos, taking the subject out of the moral sciences. The American Economic Association (1885) and the British Economic Association (1890, later the Royal Economic Society) adopted the new word.
Several forces pushed in the same direction:
- Scientific status. “Economics” sounded like physics or mathematics. The marginalists wanted a mathematical discipline on the model of the natural sciences.
- A new subject matter. Marginalism studied the choices of individuals and the formation of prices rather than the classes and the wealth of nations (Topic 8).
- Distance from politics. After Marx, the Paris Commune of 1871, and the rise of socialist parties, “political” sounded partisan. Hunt argues that a neutral-sounding name suited a profession that wanted to stand above class conflict.
- A division of labor among the social sciences. In the same decades, sociology (a name coined by Auguste Comte in the 1830s), political science, and anthropology became separate disciplines. The politics, institutions, and social relations that political economy had held together were divided among them.
Lionel Robbins sealed the change in An Essay on the Nature and Significance of Economic Science (1932), defining economics as “the science which studies human behaviour as a relationship between ends and scarce means.” The definition makes no mention of society, classes, or the state. Other languages changed more slowly: German long used Nationalökonomie or Volkswirtschaftslehre (“national economics”) within the broader Staatswissenschaften, the sciences of the state, and French used économie politique well into the twentieth century. In Chinese, 政治经济学 (political economy) was the older term, and 经济学 (economics) now names the discipline; 政治经济学 today usually means Marxian political economy.
The return of political economy
Since the 1960s the old name has come back with several meanings. Radical political economy, organized in the United States around the Union for Radical Political Economics (1968), uses it deliberately for the classical and Marxian traditions that Hunt surveys in his last chapter (Topic 25). International political economy is a field of political science that studies trade, finance, and power among states. And within mainstream economics, “political economy” now often means the economic analysis of politics: elections, institutions, and lobbying.
| Period | Name of the field | Where it lived | Central questions |
|---|---|---|---|
| Before c. 1750 | Part of moral philosophy; “oeconomy” as household management; cameralism | Faculties of philosophy; royal administration | Ethics, natural law, the wealth and power of the state |
| c. 1750–1870 | Political economy | Chairs of political economy; the moral sciences | The wealth of nations; value; distribution among classes |
| c. 1870–1930 | Economics | Separate economics degrees and professional associations | Individual choice, prices, and the allocation of scarce means |
| Since the 1960s | Economics, with a revived “political economy” | Economics departments; radical and international political economy | Both, with a running debate over which questions matter |
2. The surplus product
Every society must produce enough to feed, clothe, and house its members and to replace the tools, seed, and materials used up in production. Whatever is produced beyond that is the surplus product. How large it is, who controls it, and how it is used are among the most important facts about any society.
Dividing the total product
For most of human history, perhaps 99 percent of it, people lived in small foraging societies with little or no surplus and no permanent hierarchy. Agriculture, which began about 10,000 years ago, made a regular surplus possible. With it came classes that lived from the surplus without producing it, states, armies, priesthoods, and cities. In different societies the surplus was taken as tribute, as labor services, as rent, or as taxes, and spent on palaces, temples, wars, and luxury. What was new about capitalism was that a large part of the surplus would be reinvested to produce still more surplus.
3. Feudalism and its crisis
After the collapse of the Western Roman Empire, Western Europe was organized around the manor. Serfs were bound to the land; they farmed their own plots and owed the lord labor on his land, a share of their crops, or payments, in return for protection and the right to stay. The surplus was extracted by custom and force, not through markets, and was mostly consumed by lords, the church, and the crown.
Between about 1000 and 1300, Europe’s population and output grew: the three-field system, heavier ploughs, and horses raised yields; towns revived; trade expanded. Then came crisis. Famine struck in the 1310s, and the Black Death of 1347–51 killed somewhere between a third and a half of Europe’s population. Labor became scarce. Lords tried to hold wages down and tighten serfdom, and peasants revolted, in France (1358) and in England (1381). Over the following century serfdom faded in Western Europe, as labor services were commuted into money rents and many peasants gained more freedom.
4. The transition to capitalism
Capitalism here means an economy in which production is organized by owners of capital who hire wage workers to produce commodities for sale at a profit, and reinvest the profit. Several long processes created it:
- Long-distance trade and merchant capital. Italian, Flemish, and later Dutch and English merchants grew rich by trade and finance. Merchants began to organize production directly through the putting-out system, supplying raw materials to rural households and selling the finished cloth.
- Enclosure. In England, rising demand for wool from the fifteenth century led landlords to fence common fields for sheep. Peasants lost access to land and became a class with nothing to sell but their labor.
- Conquest and the price revolution. After 1492, Spanish conquest of the Americas sent a flood of silver into Europe. Prices rose several-fold over the sixteenth century, which squeezed those on fixed incomes, including landlords with customary rents, and favored merchants and enterprising farmers.
- The nation-state. Monarchs built standing armies and bureaucracies financed by taxes and borrowing, and they used state power to promote trade, colonies, and manufacturing.
The logic of the new system is captured by a simple formula. A merchant or industrialist begins with money (M), buys commodities (C), and sells them for more money (M′). The point is not the use of the goods but the increase in money, and the process starts again with M′:
M – C – M′ – C – M″ – …
Where the increment comes from is the central puzzle of political economy. The mercantilists found it in trade; the physiocrats in agriculture; Smith and Ricardo in labor; Marx in unpaid labor (Topic 6); the marginalists in the productivity of capital and the reward for waiting (Topics 8–9).
5. The arithmetic of growth
Angus Maddison’s historical estimates for Britain suggest that income per person grew at almost zero percent a year in the first millennium, about 0.1 percent a year from 1000 to 1500, about 0.2 percent from 1500 to 1820, and about 1.4 percent a year after 1820. These differences look small, but compounding makes them enormous. A useful rule: a quantity growing at g percent a year doubles in about 70 ÷ g years.
What a growth rate means over time
Modern economic growth began with the Industrial Revolution, which replaced human and animal muscle and wood with coal and, later, oil and gas. Explaining why it began in northwestern Europe, and whether it can continue on a finite planet (Topics 22–23), are questions that run through the history of economic thought.
6. Mercantilism
The first sustained writing on the economy came from merchants and royal advisers between the sixteenth and eighteenth centuries, later grouped together as mercantilists. They were not a school with a single doctrine, but they shared some common views:
- A nation’s wealth and power depend on its stock of gold and silver.
- A nation without mines gains precious metals through a favorable balance of trade: exporting more than it imports.
- The state should therefore encourage exports and manufacturing, restrict imports, and acquire colonies as sources of raw materials and markets.
The ordinary means therefore to encrease our wealth and treasure is by Forraign Trade, wherein wee must ever observe this rule; to sell more to strangers yearly than wee consume of theirs in value.Thomas Mun, England’s Treasure by Forraign Trade (written c. 1630, published 1664)
Mercantilists explained profit as arising in exchange, from buying cheap and selling dear. But what one trader gains, another loses; this can explain one nation’s gain at another’s expense, but not how the world as a whole grows richer. Later mercantilists such as William Petty began to look at production and labor: Petty argued that “labour is the father and active principle of wealth, as lands are the mother.” Adam Smith built his Wealth of Nations in part as an attack on what he called the “mercantile system.”
7. The physiocrats
In mid-eighteenth-century France, a group around François Quesnay, physician to Louis XV, argued that only agriculture produces a surplus, the produit net (net product), because nature cooperates with labor on the land; manufacturing and trade merely transform or move what agriculture produces. They called themselves économistes; their name, “physiocrats,” means rule of nature.
Quesnay’s Tableau économique (1758) traced how the annual product circulates among three classes: farmers (the productive class), landowners (who receive the net product as rent), and artisans and merchants (the “sterile” class). It was the first model of the economy as a circular flow, an ancestor of both Marx’s reproduction schemes and modern input–output tables. The physiocrats’ policy conclusions were radical for absolutist France: abolish internal tolls and the regulations on the grain trade, and replace France’s many taxes with a single tax on the net product of land. Their slogan, laissez faire, laissez passer, would outlive them.
Readings
Core reading
Hunt, ch. 1 (Introduction: a definition of capitalism, precapitalist European economy, the transition to capitalism).
Hunt, ch. 2 (Economic Ideas Before Adam Smith).
Companion reading
Heilbroner, The Worldly Philosophers, ch. 2 (The Economic Revolution).
Stilwell, Political Economy: The Contest of Economic Ideas, ch. 5–7.